|
| Recent
Articles |
Europe's Competition Double Standard
When it comes to US-based companies like Microsoft and Apple, the European Union thinks they should open the doors on their intellectual property to competitors; when it comes to municipalities competing with broadband providers, the EU's stance is downright American.
Google And 520 Domain Names
The list of domain names owned by the Googleplex consists of the expected, the unexpected...
Telcos Slash Prices In Response to VoIP
The popularity of voice-over-Internet-protocol (VoIP) telephony services is pushing the telecommunications industry to cut prices as customers jump ship for cheaper voice services.
Time Warner, Others To Pay $23M Settlement
Accusations of fraud and improper accounting practices at AOL led to lawsuits against Time Warner in 2004 because of their effect on pension and investment funds...
Feds Infighting Over College Wiretapping
US Senator Lamar Alexander and his ex-staffer Deborah Taylor Tate now occupy opposing positions...
Net Neutrality Amendment Shot Down
Telecommunications giants scored a victory over Net Neutrality advocates in the U.S. legislature yesterday...
No More AOL Free Hours
Heh. When America Online made the strange move of renaming themselves to an ancronym that no longer stands for anything (AOL LLC) and made dial-up and broadband cost the same...
Google, EarthLink Win S.F. WiFi Deal
The City of San Francisco finished its review of proposals to create a city-wide wireless broadband network, and chose the EarthLink/Google submission...
FCC Sucks, Says Google Lawyer
The war of words between major content providers and the telecom companies escalated nicely during the opening of the VON conference in San Jose...
Telco Money Grab Numbers Revealed
All those billions of dollars the telecom companies want to snatch from content providers gain a bit of context thanks to BellSouth chief architect Henry Kafka.
Net Neutrality Foes To Merge
Outspoken advocates of a two-tiered Internet will soon share a single corporate structure as AT&T will shell out $67 billion to acquire BellSouth.
Senator Proposes Net Neutrality Bill
Ron Wyden (D-Or) has introduced legislation to prevent telecoms and cable companies from developing a two-tiered network where fees would be charged to content providers to prioritize their Internet traffic.
Google, EarthLink Pair On Two-Tiered WiFi
The two companies submitted competing bids during San Francisco's call for wireless broadband proposals, but have now teamed on a single proposal that will offer...
AOL Launching Host of New AIM Services
USA Today reports AOL is planning to launch a whole host of new services as its shift from a subscriber model to an advertising strategy.
|
|
|
|
07.21.06
Time Compares Apples To Goodmail
 By
Jason Lee Miller
If a fish salesman's brother tells you his brother's fish is the best in town, do you take his word for it? Or would you think it, um, fishy? So when AOL's brother releases a report that use of Goodmail's Certified Email resulted in a 30% increase in response, shouldn't we subject it to the same scrutiny?
Magazine publisher Time Inc., a subsidiary of AOL sibling Time Warner, announced this week that a three-month test of CertifiedEmail's trusted icon system yielded a 30% overall increase in positive response rates.
Time sent emails to the AOL accounts of active subscribers to its various publications, which includes Fortune, Business 2.0, and Sports Illustrated, with options to manage or renew subscriptions, pay bills, or make changes to their account.
From the release:
Compared to the non-CertifiedEmail messages, subscribers who received CertifiedEmail messages showed the following index scores:
Click-through rate: 130 percent Site login: 128 percent Customer service option selected: 127 percent
"The business benefits of CertifiedEmail - assured delivery of messages to our subscribers with all links and images presented intact - had a clear impact on results," said Ernie Vickroy, a marketing director at Time Consumer Marketing, Inc. "Trusted, authenticated CertifiedEmail messages resulted in higher click-throughs, and improved program response rates."
Now nothing gets the emarketer's attention more than the phrase "click-through rate." But is this a fair comparison? Authenticated emails, delivered with images and links in tact, received more response than emails delivered without images and links in tact.
It's no secret that unless an emailer is on the EnhancedWhitelist, the apparent phase out of which sparked so much controversy for AOL earlier this year, or is using the CertifiedEmail system, that the branding and the functionality of emails sent is severely downgraded. ISPs routinely disable links and images in emails as a security measure.
Let's imagine it another way. Let's say Ford brokers a deal with Goodyear so that Goodyear tires are the preferred brand of tires for Ford cars, and the two begin cross-promoting. Jaguar, owned by Ford, publishes (hypothetically) Awesome Tires Magazine. Awesome Tires Magazine compares Goodyear tires with a competing brand of tires.
The researchers remove the valve caps and tread from the competing tires and conclude, after three months of research, that cars with Goodyear tires arrived at their destinations faster and with fewer mishaps.
While that is true, the researchers were using handicapped tires for their comparison, much like emails sent without authentication were handicapped. Apples. Oranges. But the conclusion sure makes an impression with drivers who just read the headlines.
For a more recent example, let's consider the Cingular Wireless controversy over a commercial claiming an independent research company said Cingular has the fewest dropped calls of any national carrier. Sprint filed suit against Cingular because of the ad, claiming that the company didn't have the data to back that up.
The research firm was Telephia, who expressed disappointment that Cingular had released the name of the company and said that they only provided the statistics. Interpretation of the statistics was left to Cingular.
Sprint also countered by noting the phone used to conduct Cingular's road testing. Telephia used the Motorola T720 phone, which in addition to not being widely used for two years, also has an external antenna which gets better reception than the majority of phones used today with internal antennas. Again, it's an unfair comparison.
So the conclusion of this study is to take Time Inc.'s findings with a grain of salt. This isn't to say Goodmail is not a valid and good option for sending bulk email. It is a valid and good option, especially for institutions that handle sensitive client information.
But AOL has an economic interest in getting bulk emailers to use Goodmail and the apparent plan to require the switch received astounding negative response. Six months later, an AOL-affiliated company releases apples-to-oranges comparisons that yielded positive results for it, and champions another AOL-affiliated company.
And that automatically makes it fishy.
About the Author:
Jason L. Miller is a staff writer for WebProNews covering technology and business.
|
